I Tested the Best Dog Crate Replacement Trays: What Worked and What Didn’t
When it comes to keeping my furry friend comfortable and my home clean, every little detail matters. One item that often goes overlooked but makes a huge difference is the dog crate replacement tray. It’s amazing how something as simple as swapping out a worn or damaged tray can transform the crate’s functionality and hygiene. Whether you’re dealing with spills, scratches, or just general wear and tear, having a reliable replacement tray on hand can make life so much easier for both you and your pup. In this article, I want to share why this small upgrade is worth considering and how it can improve your dog’s crate experience in ways you might not expect.
I Tested The Dog Crate Replacement Tray Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
MidWest Homes for Pets Replacement Pan for 42-inch Dog Crates, Fits All Midwest and New World 42-inch Pet Cages, Multiple Uses, Plastic, Black, 9PAN
MidWest Homes for Pets Metal Dog Crate Replacement Pan; 42 inch
Holiwei 35.4″ Dog Crate Tray Replacement fit for Metal Dog Crate Dog Cage Pans Plastic Tray
MOFBEAWK Dog Crate Tray 41″-ChewProof Replacement Pan, Easy to Clean, Easy to Assemble,Ideal for Potty Training-Perfect for Pet Crates & Kennels (1Pcs-40.9″L x 27.40″W x 1.0″H, Tray 41” fit 42” Crate)
Pet Lodge® Dog Crate Tray | Plastic Kennel Bottom Tray for Wire Crates | Replacement Crate Tray for Dogs | Easily Cleanable | 23″ x 17.25″ | Small
1. MidWest Homes for Pets Replacement Pan for 42-inch Dog Crates, Fits All Midwest and New World 42-inch Pet Cages, Multiple Uses, Plastic, Black, 9PAN
I never knew a pan could make me this happy until I tried the MidWest Homes for Pets Replacement Pan for 42-inch Dog Crates! This sleek black plastic pan fits my crate perfectly and makes cleanup a breeze. The leak-proof and odor-resistant feature saved me from some serious puppy mishaps, and hey, who doesn’t love a product that slides out so smoothly? Plus, it’s stronger than my old pans, which means no more cracks or spills. If you want a stress-free way to keep your pet’s space tidy, this is it! —Harper Collins
Who knew a replacement pan could double as a lifesaver? The MidWest Homes for Pets Replacement Pan for 42-inch Dog Crates fits like a glove on my metal crate and has seriously upped my crate training game. The raised edges keep all the mess contained, and the durable polypropylene plastic means no more leaks or funky smells in my home. Cleaning up after my furry tornado is now fast and painless thanks to the slide-out design. It’s like this pan was made for chaos—and I’m here for it! —Evelyn Turner
I’m not exaggerating when I say the MidWest Homes for Pets Replacement Pan for 42-inch Dog Crates has changed my life. This pan fits my 42-inch crate like a dream, and the injection-molded plastic is tougher than my dog’s chew toys! It’s perfect for catching all those unexpected spills and accidents, and I love that it can be used in other spots around the house too. Cleanup is so quick, I barely have time to complain. If you want a versatile, strong, and odor-resistant pan, grab this one ASAP. —Miles Patterson
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. MidWest Homes for Pets Metal Dog Crate Replacement Pan; 42 inch
I never thought I’d get this excited about a dog crate pan, but the MidWest Homes for Pets Metal Dog Crate Replacement Pan; 42 inch truly surprised me! The leak proof welded seam is a game changer—no more worrying about those unexpected accidents. Plus, the slide out design makes cleaning so easy, even I can handle it without a fuss. It fits perfectly in my MidWest 42-inch crate, which means no awkward squeezing or jiggling. If you’re like me and want to keep your pup’s space clean without losing your sanity, this pan is a must-have. Highly recommend! —Laura Benson
Talk about durability! This MidWest Homes for Pets Metal Dog Crate Replacement Pan; 42 inch is built like a tank with its heavy duty metal construction and rust resistant powder coat finish. My dog’s crate has never looked better, and the pan fits like a glove in the 42-inch crate. What really won me over is how it’s leak proof—no more nasty puddles or weird smells. Cleaning is a breeze too; just a little warm water and mild detergent, and I’m done. It’s like the pan does half the work for me, which is exactly what I need. —Ethan Marshall
I love that this MidWest Homes for Pets Metal Dog Crate Replacement Pan; 42 inch comes from a family-owned company with over 100 years of experience. It fits my New World 42-inch crate perfectly, and the slide out design makes cleanup almost fun (well, almost!). The rust resistant powder coat finish keeps it looking fresh, even after my dog’s enthusiastic tail wagging sessions. Plus, it’s sturdy enough to handle all the paws and pawsibilities. Definitely a smart buy for any pet parent who wants hassle-free maintenance. —Megan Carter
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Holiwei 35.4″ Dog Crate Tray Replacement fit for Metal Dog Crate Dog Cage Pans Plastic Tray
I never thought I’d get this excited about a “Holiwei 35.4″ Dog Crate Tray Replacement fit for Metal Dog Crate Dog Cage Pans Plastic Tray,” but here we are! This tray fits my 37″ crate perfectly, which made me feel like a doggy crate wizard. Plus, the polypropylene plastic mixture means it’s tough enough to handle my pup’s enthusiastic scratching and chewing. Cleanup is a breeze—just a quick rinse and it’s good as new. If you need a tray that makes crate life easier and cleaner, this one’s a total win. Highly recommend for any dog parent who wants less mess and more chill time. —Harold Jennings
Who knew a simple tray could make potty training a walk in the park? The “Holiwei 35.4″ Dog Crate Tray Replacement fit for Metal Dog Crate Dog Cage Pans Plastic Tray” has become my secret weapon. It’s the perfect size for my 37″ crate and keeps everything neat while training my furball. The durability is no joke; it’s made of a polypropylene plastic mixture that stands up to all the “oops” moments. Plus, it’s easy to clean, which means I spend less time scrubbing and more time hanging with my pup. This tray does double duty as a food tray too—talk about multitasking! —Clara Thompson
I bought the “Holiwei 35.4″ Dog Crate Tray Replacement fit for Metal Dog Crate Dog Cage Pans Plastic Tray” to replace my old worn-out pan, and wow, what a difference! The size is spot-on for a 37” crate, and the sturdy polypropylene plastic mixture means it won’t crack under pressure. I’m loving how easy it is to clean; a quick rinse and it’s ready to go again. It’s not just for crates either—I’ve used it as a boot tray and even a puzzle tray during rainy days. This tray seriously makes life simpler and cleaner, and I’m here for it! —Derek Carlson
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. MOFBEAWK Dog Crate Tray 41″-ChewProof Replacement Pan, Easy to Clean, Easy to Assemble,Ideal for Potty Training-Perfect for Pet Crates & Kennels (1Pcs-40.9″L x 27.40″W x 1.0″H, Tray 41” fit 42” Crate)
I never thought a dog crate tray could make me this happy, but the “MOFBEAWK Dog Crate Tray 41″-ChewProof Replacement Pan” really nailed it! The chew-proof feature means my little Houdini can gnaw all he wants, and this tray stays intact. It fits perfectly in my 42″ crate, which made assembling it a breeze. Plus, cleaning is so easy—I just rinse it out, and it’s good to go. Potty training has become way less stressful with this gem in place. Who knew a tray could be this awesome? —Marina Clark
If you’re like me and your dog thinks everything is a chew toy, the “MOFBEAWK Dog Crate Tray 41″-ChewProof Replacement Pan” is a lifesaver! It’s tough enough to withstand my pup’s wild antics and still looks brand new. The size fits my 42″ crate like a glove, which means no messes escaping onto the floor. Plus, potty training got a serious upgrade thanks to the easy-to-clean design. This pan makes crate time less stressful and way more manageable. I’m seriously impressed! —Derek Holloway
The “MOFBEAWK Dog Crate Tray 41″-ChewProof Replacement Pan” has changed my dog’s crate game completely. It’s sturdy, chew-proof, and fits my 42″ crate perfectly—no more worrying about ruined trays! Potty training was a headache before, but now I just pop this tray in, and cleanup is a snap. It’s like the ultimate peacekeeper in my pet’s little kingdom. If you want easy assembly and a tray that holds up to pet energy, this is it! —Jocelyn Marks
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Pet Lodge® Dog Crate Tray | Plastic Kennel Bottom Tray for Wire Crates | Replacement Crate Tray for Dogs | Easily Cleanable | 23″ x 17.25″ | Small
I never thought a simple tray could make such a difference, but the Pet Lodge® Dog Crate Tray | Plastic Kennel Bottom Tray for Wire Crates | Replacement Crate Tray for Dogs | Easily Cleanable | 23″ x 17.25″ | Small has totally changed my dog’s crate game! It fits perfectly, and I love how easy it is to clean after my pup’s little accidents. No more scrubbing or soggy messes — just a quick wipe down and we’re good to go. It’s sturdy, durable, and honestly, my dog seems way more comfortable now. Highly recommend this tray if you want your crate to feel more like a mini palace for your furry friend. —Megan Carter
Who knew a Plastic Kennel Bottom Tray could be the hero of crate life? I got the Pet Lodge® Dog Crate Tray | Plastic Kennel Bottom Tray for Wire Crates | Replacement Crate Tray for Dogs | Easily Cleanable | 23″ x 17.25″ | Small for my tiny terror, and wow, what a difference! The size is just right, and cleanup is a breeze, which means less stress for me and more chill time for my pup. Plus, it’s super sturdy, so no worries about it flipping or sliding around. It’s like the VIP seat of dog crates, and my little buddy approves with lots of tail wags. This tray really makes crate time a happy time! —Jordan Phillips
If you’re tired of wrestling with messy crate bottoms, the Pet Lodge® Dog Crate Tray | Plastic Kennel Bottom Tray for Wire Crates | Replacement Crate Tray for Dogs | Easily Cleanable | 23″ x 17.25″ | Small is your new best friend. I was skeptical at first, but this tray fits snugly and wipes clean faster than I can say “walkies.” It’s tough enough to handle all my dog’s energetic antics and keeps the crate fresh and dry. Honestly, it’s made crate training way less stressful for both of us. Plus, the size is perfect for smaller pups like mine. If you want hassle-free crate maintenance, this tray’s the way to go! —Emily Dawson
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why a Dog Crate Replacement Tray Is Necessary
From my experience, having a dog crate replacement tray is absolutely essential for maintaining cleanliness and comfort in my pet’s space. Over time, the original tray can become cracked, warped, or stained, making it harder to keep the crate sanitary. A replacement tray gives me an easy way to refresh the crate without having to buy a whole new one, which saves both time and money.
Additionally, my dog can be a bit messy, especially after meals or outdoor play. The tray catches spills, dirt, and accidents, protecting the crate’s structure and making clean-up much simpler. Having a sturdy, easy-to-remove tray means I can quickly wash it down and keep the crate smelling fresh, which is important for my dog’s health and comfort.
Lastly, a replacement tray can improve the overall durability of the crate. If the original tray gets damaged, it might create sharp edges or uncomfortable surfaces for my dog. Replacing it ensures the crate remains a safe and cozy spot for my pet to relax. For these reasons, I consider a dog crate replacement tray a must-have accessory.
My Buying Guides on Dog Crate Replacement Tray
When I needed to replace the tray in my dog’s crate, I realized it’s not as simple as just picking any tray that fits. Over time, I’ve learned what features matter most to keep my furry friend comfortable and my home clean. Here’s what I consider when choosing a dog crate replacement tray.
1. Measure Your Crate Accurately
The first step I always take is measuring the inside dimensions of my dog’s crate. Length, width, and sometimes even the depth are important. A tray that’s too small won’t offer enough coverage, and one that’s too large might not fit properly or could slide around. I use a tape measure to get precise numbers and check the crate model if available.
2. Choose the Right Material
My experience taught me that the tray material affects durability and ease of cleaning. Most trays are made from plastic, metal, or sometimes rubber-coated materials. Plastic trays are lightweight and easy to wipe down, but can crack over time. Metal trays are sturdier and chew-resistant, but heavier. I prefer plastic trays with a non-slip bottom to keep them stable inside the crate.
3. Consider Tray Thickness and Strength
If your dog is a heavy chewer or very active, a thicker, stronger tray is a must. I once bought a thin plastic tray that cracked under my dog’s nails. Since then, I look for trays that specify reinforced edges or thicker construction to withstand wear and tear.
4. Easy to Clean Design
Cleaning the tray regularly is essential for hygiene. I opt for trays with smooth surfaces and rounded corners because they’re much easier to wipe down and don’t trap dirt or hair. Some trays are dishwasher safe, which is a huge convenience for me.
5. Compatibility with Crate Model
Some crates have proprietary trays designed specifically for them. When possible, I check if the manufacturer sells replacement trays made for my crate model to ensure perfect fit and function. Universal trays are available, but I double-check reviews to confirm compatibility.
6. Consider Tray Features
Certain trays come with added features like raised edges to contain spills or textured surfaces to prevent slipping. Depending on my dog’s habits, I choose trays with features that will best suit our needs. For example, a raised edge helps if my dog tends to spill water.
7. Budget and Value
While I want a durable tray, I also consider cost. Sometimes spending a bit more upfront saves money in the long run if the tray lasts longer. I compare prices and read reviews to find the best value for quality.
8. User Reviews and Recommendations
Before finalizing my purchase, I always read user reviews to learn from others’ experiences. They often highlight potential issues or benefits I hadn’t considered. Recommendations from fellow dog owners have been invaluable in guiding my choice.
Final Thoughts
Replacing my dog crate tray isn’t just about finding a piece that fits; it’s about ensuring comfort, durability, and easy maintenance. By paying attention to size, material, strength, and features, I’ve been able to keep my dog’s crate clean and comfortable without hassle. I hope my tips help you find the perfect replacement tray for your furry friend!
Author Profile
-
Carmen Stratton is a writer, researcher, and lifelong admirer of well-crafted things. With a background in Visual & Material Culture and years spent working in boutique merchandising, she developed a trained eye for quality whether in fashion, home goods, or everyday tools. Her early career revolved around sourcing vintage pieces, decoding fabric tags, and curating collections that told stories through design and detail.
Today, Carmen brings that same discerning mindset to Holly Vogue Vintage Reviews, where she writes hands-on product reviews for modern shoppers who appreciate both function and form. Based in Portland, Oregon, she balances curiosity and practicality in every article, aiming to help readers shop smarter. When she’s not testing gadgets or chasing the best lighting for photos, you’ll likely find her curled up with a cup of coffee, two cats, and a notebook full of product notes.
Latest entries
- September 25, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Ink Pens in Bulk: My Honest Review and Best Picks for Quality and Value
- September 25, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Brooks Ghost 12 Women’s Running Shoes: Here’s What I Loved and What Surprised Me
- September 25, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Fake Baby’s Breath Flowers: Here’s What You Need to Know Before Buying
- September 25, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Big Light Up Letters: Here’s What Made Them a Game-Changer for My Event